Disobedience


A woman returns to her Orthodox Jewish home after the death of his father, who was a Rabbi. Public outrage is of interest arising from her childhood friend.

Director:
  • Sebastián Lelio

Stars:
Release Date: 2018-04-27
IMDb icon 6.6/10
  • Country: IE, GB, US
  • Language: English
  • Runtime: 1h:54m
reviews
Gabie Mazonson
28 July 2018 | 11:59

Freedom is different. Every person perceives it in the extent of his depravity, a well-developed imagination and fear accepted in society norms. However, freedom is always freedom, no matter what terrible and disgusting form she is not accepted. Of this one thing is clear, joke with this case is impossible. The more urge.

Freedom is often controversial. If otherwise, it would sense. A good example of the conflict between word and deed, truth and consequences, the signifier and the signified. Hardly Rabbi Krushka assumed that the calling to freedom in his last speech, he giving indirect consent to the ratio of the daughter with a woman. What plead guilty to the destruction of the family and many years of solitude. Because the daughter had every right to leave where her freedom of choice was an empty sound.

By the way, the daughter, a young and successful photographer for the name of Ronit, fully assimilated into the foreign metropolis like he owned the right from the start. In many respects this way because a strong, independent woman hardly there is a place in the Orthodox Jewish community. She was born there, but no childhood memories, or, even more people the past does not connect it with this place. She is different. Too imbued with the spirit of freedom, dwell with her nowhere. Radically and ruthlessly a girl once, long ago severed all connection father. Funny and pointless her attempts for a while to join in this is a conservative society after the death of the parent.

The mystery remains of when it was split and the left, but definitely it is associated esti. In contrast girlfriend, she remained home, humble and ashamed. Silent resistance, in which to confess in front of him hard, hardly requires less mental effort and work than open defiance. However, the satisfaction and does not smell. Ugly wig, unloved husband, the role of darkness as a standard behavior of women in society. The dam will definitely burst. It remains to wait for the right occasion, and now, the figure of old friends already. looming on the horizon.

The at least, the only person who's not afraid to invite the fugitive to home Dovid. The most, the beloved disciple of the father and unloved husband girlfriend one person. Young old fashioned man. Decent enough that for these are correct and the order is ready to step on the throat. To admit, the notion of correctness of a girl in a few changed that, in part, and makes it the dramatic character of the story.

Forms of defiance in the film, three as the number of whales to which the legend of the ancients, rests the earth. Escape from the house can be called an open protest, courage, growing up and ungrateful. All will be true. All will be the manifestation of freedom. Just as and the internal resistance all that makes it impossible to breathe and feel yourself. Strange to see the freedom in making choice of another. However, disobedience to accepted standards is best suited for the definition of freedom. She always different, as the time. She always one, as the life you will live.

Bibbie Korenblat
10 July 2018 | 12:53

Photographer lady Ronit Krushka once left home and went to new York, escaped from conservative religious atmosphere of the Jewish community. But once she gets the message that her father is the Rabbi died. Ronit has to return to where it is almost never waiting on the spot finds out that her best friend Dovid Kuperman is married to their common friend, esti. Once between her and Ronit was something more than a simple manifestation of friendly feelings, and now the flame is suppressed for years of passion just waiting to burst out. But environment where the lives of esti, is unlikely to help them a joint happiness.

Chilean Director Sebastian Lelio, whose "Fantastic woman" was the first picture from this country, which won the "Oscar" in the category "best foreign film", moved on to a new project on the topic of non-traditional relationships. At this time this movie is in English, with Hollywood stars in the lead roles, here to say "Disobedience", filmed at the debut novel, Naomi Alderman, became his creative step forward. "Fantastic woman" is hardly a masterpiece, but it was a good, confident shot picture with a nice direction "under Almodovar". Here, at the primary language with the Spanish English, seemed to have disappeared many nuances. Lelio well demonstrated by the stifling of religious pressure and his domestic environment, painted pale colors, slow, exhausting-boring and forcing young women to wear wigs and marry "because so it should be" in General, as people. But this apathy, to unfortunately, often goes to the demonstration of the relationships of the characters — here the Director is also very dry and style Director at all seem too distant, lifeless, and even some emotional love scenes don't look colorful splash.

Problems built on the old tired cliches of the LGBT melodramas: "we love each other, but together we not be destiny", aggressive-minded religious relatives/neighbors and, as a consequence, problems on the job/house, plenty of internal conflict between obedience to public opinion, debt and heart and more. Especially deep Lelio not immersed in those things which are considered rather banal and monotonous, because of what the fate of the heroines is not a helluva lot of touches to the mid at all tiring and makes openly available. Not gets the expected heart-rending catharsis even the final set melodramatic and extremely fresh. What and pull the film at the above average, so it's a great game both Rachel — Weiss McAdams, but the first is especially good, playing the role of Ronit as a woman who had long ceased to hope for happiness begin with believes the successful outcome of any attempts to arrange his personal life as want itself.

P. S. and agree, not in every movie you see the laureate of "Oscar" Weiss spits in the mouth of a nominee McAdams.

Raychel Sergent
21 July 2018 | 03:38

I was waiting for "Disobedience" drama of the confrontation of religion (in the film is no many, little of the Orthodox Jews) and love she does not recognize, and got a story about a personal choice of responsibility for oneself.

Noble namesakes Weisz and McAdams to watch it was very nice: both well accustomed to the role, both looked quite affirmative with their sad confused eyes that spoke louder than words.

Still liked the camera work with long plans and slow assaults, and also selected General rainy-grey tone pattern in General, created a melancholic and leisurely narrative, perfect for evening getting acquainted with him in yourself.

As "Disobedience" is pretty terse movie about the explanation for the final choice of the heroine can only guess. Well, or to read the novel for which it removed.

Overall, a good and beautiful movie without a dashing plot twists and unnecessary drama — all as in life.

More! Special thanks to the creators for used in one key points and the credits Friday I'm in love with which me involves a lot of memories, so that even managed to penetrate.

faq
How long is Disobedience?
2h 34m
Who is the director of the movie Disobedience?
This tv-show was directed by Sebastián Lelio.
What is the genre of Disobedience?
The tv-show belongs to the genres of Drama, Romance, Best Drama Movies 2018, Best Romance Movies 2018.
Who starred in Disobedience?
Many famous actors starred in this tv-show, here are the names of the most famous: Rachel Weisz, Rachel McAdams, Alessandro Nivola, Anton Lesser, Cara Horgan.
What is Disobedience IMDB Ranking?
At the moment, the rating is 6.6.
When was Disobedience released?
The start date for this tv-show on USA TV is 2018-04-27.